Here are 15 Why Choose books that I can personally recommend, all involving the fae, faeries, or elves! I enjoyed every single book on this list, and I hope you do, too.
Last I checked, all of them were in Kindle Unlimited!
Don’t forget to join the Why Choose? Romance Club Facebook group to hang out with other RH readers.
Fae, Faerie, Elf Reverse Harem Book Collection
Hit Buy on Amazon below to be taken to Amazon, where you can buy or borrow with KU!
Power of Five
by Alex Lidell
No list of fae RH books would be complete without The Power of Five! Four immortal fae are bound by magic to a female mortal instead of a powerful fae warrior like themselves.
Trigger warnings: Past sexual abuse and PTSD
Piece of Dragon
by Laurel Chase
I absolutely loved this entire series. It even made it to my favorites list on Goodreads! The fae realm has been cut off from Earth, leaving fae stranded forever… Unless a rare unicorn shifter can save them.
Trigger warnings: Dub-con, abuse, violence against women
by C.M. Stunich & Tate James
This dark series takes you on a wild ride following the reincarnated goddess and leader of the Wild Hunt! If you like the thought of mixing fae magic with a badass motorcycle club, this is the series for you!
Trigger warnings: dark themes, blood, violence, sex, swearing, torture
Bound by Magic
by Sadie Moss
One badass ex-mercenary becomes bound to four sexy-as-sin men who will do anything to protect her. She thought she was powerless, but it turns out she’s anything but.
Elemental Fae Academy
by Lexi C. Foss & J.R. Thorn
In this medium-burn RH, our leading lady falls for her elemental mentors one by one. She’s a rare breed who can access all five elements.
Away with the Faeries
by Sam Hall
This is a dark, true enemies-to-lovers RH that’s unique even among fae RH books. I’ve only read the first so far, and my only warning is that if you don’t like seeing the guys with other chicks before they get together with the FMC, this may not be the RH for you. These guys are rockstars who fool around with groupies and don’t play nice.
Trigger warnings: dub con dream
by May Dawson
The angst is real in this series where our royal leading lady lost her memories and the guys remember all the terrible things she did (but she doesn’t). Feels like an enemies to lovers. Warning: super addictive!
Rise of the Phoenix
by J.L. Madore
This is a very polyamorous RH with lots of M/M even while the FMC isn’t around. If that’s not your thing, skip this series. Feisty, mouthy heroine and the men who are bound to her as mates to unite the fae realm… one from each type of fae shifter species. Multiple POVs.
Trigger warnings: childhood trauma/abuse/rape,
The Guardian (The Faerie Wars)
by Quinn Arthurs
When our FMC performs the final rites for her mother, three sexy fairy knights appear to escort her to a home she never knew about.
Captive of Wolves
by Eva Chase
One of my all-time favorite RH series! Only the FMC’s blood can prevent the summer fae from losing control of their wolf shifter side on a full moon. They are, of course, at war with the winter fae, who can shapeshift into ravens. Multiple POV and a must-read!
Trigger warnings: Torture and abuse
by Elle Middaugh and Ann Denton
A true enemies to lovers book without bullies! It’s her job to stop shifters, but she ends up a captive of three shifter warlords.
Fires of Hatred
by Erin O’Kane
This single-POV, super slow-burn RH is super addictive. The FMC used to be a slave and turns out to be goddess-blessed. Along the way, she feels a pull toward two mages, a prince, an imprisoned elf, and perhaps others…
Trigger warnings: Slavery, torture, child abuse
Spin the Shadows
by Cate Corvin
Such an addictive series! One of my favorite FMCs, and I love the guys. Steamy and the harem builds over time. Love how there’s a blend of magic and technology in the Fae world.
Resurrect (The Blooming Courts)
by Kendra Moreno and Poppy Woods
One of the most beautiful worlds I’ve ever visited in an RH series. Slow-burn and the harem builds over time.
The Lost Queen (Our Fae Queen)
by Traci Lovelot
And of course, here’s my own fae RH series! Only the love of five fae can convince Glori she’s meant to be queen. Slow-burn and slow-build over six books. Later books will include M/M involving the FMC.
Hit buy on Amazon to buy or borrow in Kindle Unlimited on any of the books above!
Support this site! Become a Patreon member for as little as $1 a month and cancel anytime.
Please share this collection of awesome RH books with your friends and tell them about the Club!